Welcome to the Legal Defense Website for Shontelle Cavanaugh

About Postpartum Psychosis

Home | About Postpartum Psychosis | Sign our guest book | Receive a gift with your donation | Current Events

POSTPARTUM PSYCHOSIS



 POSTPARTUM PSYCHOSIS occurs in approximately 1 in 1,000 births.
Since this disorder is unique to women and relatively rare,  there is a  lack of understanding of the disorder and failure to identify it, which has led to tragic endings including  the mishandling of these cases in our legal system.   

Postpartum psychosis is characterized by disorganized and bizarre thinking, delusions, paranoia, and hallucinations (usually voices telling her to harm herself or her baby) resulting in  homicidal and suicidal impulses and actions.

Most often, a woman with postpartum psychosis does not share her thoughts or recognize the need for help even though this is considered a psychiatric emergency.  The symptoms of the depression might be the only thing noticed by family members or health care providers, but treating depression will not help the psychosis and in some cases may make it worse.  

 Postpartum Psychosis is a Psychiatric Emergency and a Medical Emergency
 
All psychosis is medical in nature, caused by a "physical"   problem.  That includes  the illnesses of schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, depression etc.   I actually think characterizing it as just a medical condition minimizes the severity and difficulties of the condition.

Mental illness has always been difficult to understand because you can't see it. You can't do a test or even an MRI of the head to tell if someone is hallucinating or planning suicide.
 
Post-partum psychosis  is called a "psychiatric emergency"  because this particular illness usually results in uncontrollable impulses to attempt suicide and/or murder. ( The nature of the emergency would be more comparable to a trauma/motor vehicle accident  you don't see coming, because urgency in care is the most important factor in order to save lives.)
 
I think society in general understands that a person with mental illness does not have the ability to control the illness.  Antipsychotic medication, antidepressants, etc.  are prescribed more now than ever before.  The stigma is being lifted slowly.
 
A person who is psychotic has had a break with reality.  The person does not even recognize the need for treatment, or that what she may be experiencing isn't "real" at all.  Since the psychotic person doesn't recognize the experience as abnormal, she will not recognize the need to tell someone about it, or seek treatment on her own.
 
With bipolar disorder and schizoaffective disorder there is no conscious or active participation in the illness.

Unfortunately laws don't recognize that someone can be mentally ill, maintain a notion of what is right and wrong, and still have psychosis which prevents the ability to control wrong impulses.  The only reason Andrea Yates was convicted was because the jury had to follow the instructions of the law.  The jurors all believed that she was insane at the time she killed her children, Texas law said a person is criminally liable if she knew right from wrong when she committed the crime; they had no choice but to convict, and unfortunately people found guilty but mentally ill are sentenced the same as people just found guilty.
 
It is the temporary nature of post-partum psychosis that makes it difficult for people to understand, but some psychosis that is triggered by pregnancy may never go away without lifelong treatment.

Shontelle's situation is even more unique.  Her post partum psychosis triggered a latent bipolar and schizoaffective disorder.  Approximately  25% of all women with bipolar disorder present with their first episode right after childbirth.
 

 

TO LEARN MORE ABOUT POSTPARTUM PSYCHOSIS VISIT THE SITES LISTED BELOW

"The Female Patient: Postpartum Depression" Grand Rounds at the University of Michigan

Attorney George Parnham explains why defending a woman with postpartum psychosis is difficult

Read an NPR story about "One Mother's Story" and listen to the NPR interview by Joanne Silberner

Visit the website dedicated to Melanie Stokes. Postpartum psychosis caused Melanie to take her own life after the birth of her daughter.

Prosecutorial discretion seems to be lacking in Oakland County.  Overcharging a case in the hopes of attaining a conviction on "something" doesn't seem ethical and knowing when NOT to charge a case is just as important as knowing when to take one to trial.

 Barbara Morrison was the Oakland County Prosecutor who charged Shontelle Cavanaugh with first degree murder of her baby, Simone.  Morrison repeatedly fought over the past several years to keep Shontelle out of a forensic hospital where she could receive adequate treatment for her bipolar disorder.

Ironically, Barbara Morrison is now the Section Leader of the "Special Victim's Section" even though she has failed to recognize that Simone, Shontelle and Shontelle's family have all been tragic victims of post partum psychosis.

Sadly, despite having a new female County Prosecutor, Jessica Cooper, justice for women with mental health issues may not change in Oakland County with Barbara Morrison in charge of the section.

In an article written by members of the County Prosecutor's office an important line bears repeating about what they think the assistant prosecutors are hired to do and what the public expects them to do.  That is, "fight for justice in the courtroom."

But that is wrong. Justice doesn't always have to occur in a courtroom or result in a conviction, that is why in our system we have what is known as prosecutorial discretion.  The search for truth and the application of justice for all individuals should be the primary goal.


 

Copyright 2008, Convertino & Associates for the Shontelle Cavanaugh Legal Defense Fund